Home|About Us | What We Believe | Find Us | Christian Ed | GSPC Newsletter | GSPC Music | GSPC Youth

HISTORY OF GOVERNMENT STREET PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH

 

Most of the information in this history is taken from the book The Archives Tell a Story by Charles D. Bates, Executive Secretary of the Church, 1959.

 

When the Americans acquired Mobile from the Spanish during the War of 1812, the community seemed unimpressive. There were less than a thousand inhabitants, who were a mixture of French, Spanish, Blacks and Indians. They dwelled in squalid, rotting cottages. Streets were muddy, and only one or two wharves jutted out into the river, evidence of the deadening effect of the royal monopoly on trade. The population was largely male, and many frequented the numbers of bars and gambling houses on the river. The town was overwhelmingly Roman Catholic in faith. This changed as large numbers of American protestants arrived during the teens and twenties.

 

Alabama was admitted to the Union as a state in 1819. The Presbyterians were not a significant presence in early American Mobile. In 1821 the Presbytery of Alabama was organized with only three churches and fifty members.
 

In the winter of 1822 the Rev. John B. Warren, a licentiate of the Salem Association of Massachusetts, was sent by the New York Evangelical Society of Young Men to Alabama to establish a church. He became the second man to be ordained by the Presbytery of Alabama. He set about building a church two blocks east of the present structure, which is now the site of the LaClede Hotel. During his amazing and prodigious efforts to build this church his wife and daughter died in a yellow fever epidemic. He continued his work undaunted, soliciting funds from friends in the north. With his own hands he chopped logs and floated them down the river to Mobile. Once he was swamped in Pole Cat Bay, where he remained several days. Selling two houses and his meager household effects, he used the proceeds in the construction of the church. Seven difficult years were spent building the first sanctuary before it was dedicated in May of 1829.
 

Meanwhile, a small group of Presbyterians had formed a union protestant church with local Episcopalians. In 1828 the Presbyterians informally organized under the Rev. Murdock Murphy, as a Presbyterian Church in Government-Street.
 

John Warren, evidently an eccentric man who was never fully accepted by the majority of Presbyterians in the area, preached the first sermon in his new sanctuary. An extract from that sermon illustrates his feelings:

This church has not been erected to subserve the purposes of any religious party; but, as we trust, for the honor of the Redeemer, for the glory of His great and Holy Name; for the promotion of His Kingdom and Cause; and for the salvation of immortal souls. The enterprise did not originate in any feeling or motive of hostility to any other church in this city; and God forbid that it should ever be arrayed in opposition to any church where the pure doctrines of Christ are preached to prevent any misapprehension and future collision, we deem it important here to state that this church is ever to remain under the jurisdiction and control of the Presbyterian or Congregational denomination of Christians. Here let the rich and the poor meet together and remember that the Lord is maker of them all. Let not a dweller in the city while a vacant place remains ever have it in his power to say that he absents himself from the house of God because he has no seat.


 

An early historian reports that Warren, "having preached the dedication sermon, gave it (the new building) up to the Presbyterian Church which had been organized the preceding year by Reverend Murdock Murphy, and took his departure from Mobile." [i]
 

Mr. Murphy’s diary reveals that he had financial troubles due to "a want of punctuality on the part of my congregation in paying my salary. Sometimes, I received but little more than half of the thousand dollars promised me." In February of 1831 he left Mobile. He died in 1833.
 

The church was formally organized in January of 1831 with 22 charter members [ii] under Rev. James R. Johnston, Pastor. In 1834, Dr. William T. Hamilton became minister. The congregation grew, and in 1836 land at the corner of Jackson and Government Streets was purchased.
 

Mobile’s fortunes began to take an upturn, due to King Cotton. As Alabama’s only port, the city experienced tremendous growth as a cotton market. Mobile burgeoned with new residents; fortune seekers, bankers, lawyers, land speculators, cotton factors, slaves, and workingmen. From about three thousand in 1830, the population grew to over thirty thousand by the eve of the Civil War. Mobile was the third busiest port in the nation. In 1837 the Bank of Mobile had more money on deposit than any other branch in America.
 

During this time a local businessman of remarkable energy and talent emerged, without whom the construction of Government Street Presbyterian Church might not have been possible. Henry Hitchcock, a grandson of the revolutionary hero Ethan Allen, was born in New England in 1795. He came to Alabama in 1817 and began the practice of law. He was appointed territorial secretary by Governor William Bibb, he helped prepare the state constitution, and was attorney general from 1819 to 1823. He was elected to the Alabama Supreme Court in 1835.
 

Hitchcock began to shift from law to business, acquiring an interest in several local companies. He became Mobile’s first millionaire. Despite his wide ranging personal interest and investment in Mobile’s commercial life, Hitchcock was spiritually troubled. He was disturbed by a lack of deeper meaning to his life. During 1834-35 the new Presbyterian minister in Mobile, William Thomas Hamilton, boarded with the Hitchcocks. The two men became close friends, and the association had a profound affect on the businessman/lawyer. Hitchcock accepted the salvation of Jesus Christ, was baptized in 1836, and became an elder later that year.
 

Henry Hitchcock was just the man to facilitate construction of a church for his new-found faith. He had the capital, he had the business, legal and construction contacts, and he had the desire.
 

The present sanctuary was begun in 1836 and completed in 1838 at a cost of $60,000. Dr. Hamilton and Judge Hitchcock closely supervised construction. J.S. Buckingham, author of Slave States of America (London 1842), visited Mobile in March of 1839, and described the church: "Of churches, the Presbyterian is the largest and most beautiful...its interior is unsurpassed in chasteness of style and elegance of decoration in the United States. There is...a very happy union of the Egyptian and Greek purposes of the pulpit;...the rich diagonally-indented ceiling, and luxurious sofa-like pews make this interior altogether the most strikingly beautiful I ever remember to have seen."
 

The building had a steeple which housed a large clock imported from Liverpool. It also contained the city’s first fire bell. During a storm in 1852 the steeple was struck by lightning and had to be removed. Although a Ladies’ Society for the Restoration of the Steeple was formed, it was never replaced.
 

Government Street in those days was paved with wooden blocks. The loud clopping of the passing horses drifted through the open windows and disturbed worship. During heavy rains blocks floated away and had to be rescued and replaced.
 

The panic of 1837 prostrated business enterprises, and generally caused much havoc. The members of the church who had been so liberal in giving were mostly bankrupted, and the financial condition of the church became much embarrassed. A terrible fire broke out in 1839, and burned out a large section of downtown. But Mobile rose Phoenix-like from the ashes, and the church was relieved from its financial troubles by a satisfactory settlement of all existing claims.
 

The Sunday School building was completed in 1904 and dedicated to the memory of Dr. J. R. Burgett, minister of Government Street Presbyterian Church for 40 years.
 

Throughout its history, the church has had a two-fold mission: the nurturing of the flock and outreach to the community.
 

The Session Minutes record many instances of elders and/or ministers visiting with members and prospective members, examining them as to their faith, or admonishing them for actions which were perceived as injurious to the faith. The officers sought to emphasize the fact that church membership is an important step - not to be taken lightly - and should mean something to each individual. Varying forms of "worldliness" received special emphasis from year to year, and these would find their way into the questioning regarding membership, as for example, "round dancing," "temperance," and "theater attendance." But basically and at all times, the fundamental requirement has never varied - a public profession of faith in Jesus Christ.
 

In 1884, however, the Session Minutes read: "It was resolved that hereafter, in the examination of candidates for church membership, the session will not require them to answer questions which disclose their intentions as to their future action in attendance upon theaters, dancing, and other amusements; but that they be left to decide such questions according to their own interpretation of the Word of God and their own consciences; further, that they be advised not to allow these or any other pleasures to habitually interfere with their attendance upon the stated services of this church."
 

In 1864, the Minutes record: "The contributions of our church to beneficent objects have been remarkably good for the times...Besides assisting in the support of over a thousand families in this city, they have attended liberally to their own poor. They have helped to clothes our soldiers by voluntary contributions. They have sent two missionaries into the field to labor among our soldiers for three months each. They have helped to distribute Bibles and religious readings to our army. They have sent a monthly contribution of from $450 to $500 to our Domestic Board for army missions. They have supplemented their pastor’s salary in a private way until they have made it almost double what it was. Wherever liberality of this kind is needed they are never wanting, and in this regard partake of the Spirit which pervades the whole community."
 

The more things change...from 1864: "Besides the Sabbath services, we have had a weekly lecture on Thursday evening which consists of an exposition of some portion of the Scriptures, a weekly prayer meeting on Saturday evening and also on Sabbath afternoon. The attendance on these has been variable - sometimes respectably good and at other times indifferently so. The lecture seemed, in general, to draw out more hearers than the prayer meetings, which only seems a confirmation of what has often been remarked, that the more spiritual the exercises the less enjoyment do even professing Christians at large experience in them."
 

From 1874: "The Sabbath school has never been interrupted, although in the summer it is sometimes difficult to keep it going. We use the International Series of Lessons, and prefer them to any other series."
 

1877: "The Sabbath school is greatly reduced in numbers during the summer months because of the scattered condition of the congregation and the removal from the city of many families."
 

And from 1878: "Attendance upon the services of the sanctuary has been generally about the same as in former years. Although not crowded, the church is pretty well filled on Sabbath mornings when not hindered by unfavorable weather. The evening services are usually small and discouraging. Weekday services are generally well attended."
 

The first deacons were selected in 1840, the session having decided they were needed. However, in 1886, it was noted that there had been only three meetings of the deacons since 1863!
 

In November, 1842, the Second Presbyterian Church was organized by a committee of presbytery in response to a petition signed by eighteen who were members of Government Street, and who were dismissed to be enrolled members of the new church.
 

The Third Presbyterian Church was organized in 1853. By mutual agreement, the Second and Third churches united, and were joined into the Jackson Street Church. This later became known as the Central Presbyterian Church.
 

In 1852 Government Street Church built a frame edifice at the corner of Broad and Dauphin Streets, beginning a mission which became the Fourth Presbyterian Church. This church has since been dissolved, and the building later burned down.
 

The South Franklin Street Church was organized in 1872. Broad Street Presbyterian was organized in 1890; Spring Hill Presbyterian Church in 1944; Community, in 1946; Westminster, in 1955; Cottage Hill, in 1958; Grace, 1959. Many of the charter members of these churches were former members of Government Street.
 

In 1859 this church contributed $1,000 for the building of a large Presbyterian Church in Washington, D.C. (presumably the National Presbyterian Church). It also answered a request for contributions to help build a new sanctuary for the Central Presbyterian Church in 1908.
 

For many years the ladies of the church maintained the Carr Social Room, where ladies who worked downtown could come to have lunch. It was in operation from 1913 through the fifties, and many working women prepared and ate their lunches here in the building.
 

In 1893 a Chinese Sabbath School was organized at the request of some Chinese citizens of Mobile. It was well attended for some years.
 

A number of great and well-known evangelists and religious leaders have conducted meetings in this church. Among these are Dwight L. Moody and his song leader, Ira L. Sankey, Billy Sunday, Dr. George Mueller of England, Whittle and Bliss, Dr. G. Campbell Morgan, Gypsy Smith, Dr. Robert E. Speer, Dr. Charles Erdman, Dr. Kagawa of Japan and others.
 

From the year 1842 to the beginning of the war in 1861, the Presbyterian Churches of Mobile took an active and leading part in carrying on a mission among the sea-faring men. This work was conducted almost exclusively among them; and for a time, "The Bethel Church" was enrolled in the list of churches belong to the South Alabama Presbytery. A society of Presbyterian ladies contributed largely to its support. A chaplain regularly conducted services in a chapel, and a Sabbath school was held there in the afternoon. They also provided a sailors’ home, with comfortable quarters for seamen while in port, with a library and reading room.
 

It is interesting to follow the development of the women’s movement through actions of the session. In 1893 the following resolution was offered before the session, and passed at the next meeting: "It is the desire of the session in the conduct of the spiritual affairs of the church, to conform to the teachings of the sacred Scriptures and the deliverances of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church. Inasmuch as the teachings of the former and the deliverances of the latter are positively and emphatically against the conducting of promiscuous meetings and the leading in prayer in promiscuous meetings by females, the session hereby prohibits such practices in the weekday prayer meetings, the young people’s society of Christian Endeavor, or any other meetings called or authorized by the church, except such meetings, only, as are held by ladies with only ladies in attendance."
 

From the Minutes of 1894 we read: "Notice of the session being called to the fact that a lady was in the habit of expressing her views in meetings of the Christian Endeavor Society, the moderator was requested to call her attention to the resolution adopted by the session with regard to the part that should be taken by females in promiscuous meetings of worship."
 

However, by 1917: "A request having been made from the president of the Christian Endeavor Society that lady members be permitted to lead the meetings, a motion was unanimously adopted that ‘we encourage ladies to lead or take part in any meetings that they see fit.’"
 

In 1837 and ’38 yellow fever plagued the city of Mobile. Disastrous fires broke out in 1839. Many people died, leaving scores of children orphaned. The women of Mobile organized together to nurse, feed, shelter and clothe the sick, homeless and bereft. Mrs. William T. Hamilton, wife of our church’s minister, led a group of women to organize the Protestant Orphan Asylum Society in 1840. They bought a lot and built a home which was completed in 1850. The building still stands, although it is not used as a home for children now.
 

The first woman to speak from the pulpit of the church was Miss Francis E. Willard. Sometime in the 1880s she gave a ringing message for prohibition. A Miss Millard of Australia was probably the second, and Commander Evangeline Booth spoke here in the 1890s.
 

The Ladies’ Aid Society seems to have been the first organized women’s work in Government Street Church. The minutes of the period following the war have been lost, but it probably came into being during reconstruction, when the women felt that it was time for them to take a hand. In the early years they sponsored ice cream suppers, bazaars, concerts and such to raise funds for the church. It was the Ladies’ Aid which removed the doors from the pews that seemed to keep strangers out (about 1893), who replaced the old-fashioned square panes with stained glass windows, who put new carpet on the floors, and who made many other changes that would not have been possible without their assistance.
 

In 1908, a meeting was held at Government Street to organize the Alabama Synodical, the women’s parallel to the Synod. Later a local Women’s Auxiliary of Government Street was formed, with the plan of dissolving the old societies and fusing them into one. Circles were organized in neighborhoods.
 

Music has always been a large part of worship in the Presbyterian Church, and no less at GSPC. In 1854 the Minutes record, "It was decided that an election should be held to fill the vacancy of organist and leader of the choir at a salary of $400.00 per year, with the clear understanding that the organist will keep the instrument in tune after it has been repaired."
 

In 1861: "Since the new organ was placed in the gallery, very little room has been left for the choir." A committee was appointed "to ascertain and report whether any alterations could be made to give additional room for the choir." 
 

In 1865, the Minutes record: "It was unanimously resolved that John S. Holmes be appointed organist of the Government Street Church, and a committee was appointed to wait upon our present organist, Mr. Boulcott, and notify him of the change." John Holmes served as organist over 40 years, until his death in 1908. Then Miss Bertha Emery of Tennessee was chosen to take his place, at a salary of $600.00 per year. 

In 1910, a new organ was bought, and dedicated to the memory of John Holmes. This same organ, an Estey, served the church until 2001. The old organ, from 1860, was sold to the Dauphin Way Baptist Church for $500.00, and was destroyed by fire along with their building in 1935. In 2002 a new Rieger-Kloss organ, built in the Czech Republic, shipped to New Orleans, and brought from there to Mobile by 18-wheelers, was installed. The old Estey organ was sold for parts.
 

In 1869 a motion was passed that the congregation would begin using the Assembly’s New Hymnbook, and that the members of the congregation were "requested to supply themselves with the book." Mrs. Graham Stone wrote a letter to the session in 1911, "suggesting the advantages to be gained by having the word, ‘amen’ sung at the close of hymns." After discussion, "a motion was passed requesting the choir to sing ‘amen’ at the close of each hymn." (With the advent of the new Presbyterian Hymnal in 1990, that practice ceased.)
 

A Committee on Singing was appointed by the session in 1880, "with the understanding that one of its members shall take charge of the singing at the weekday meetings, and all matters pertaining thereto."
 

The chairman of the music committee reported to the session in 1882 that a complaint had been made by the organist of disorderly conduct among the young men seated in the gallery during morning worship, so much so as to prevent the choir from hearing the sermon. The moderator was requested to state from the pulpit on the next Sunday morning that such a complaint had been lodged, and "to ask for an immediate discontinuance of such noises." However, in 1908, the choir was admonished for talking during services!
 

And in 1883 a motion was passed "requesting the pastor, hereafter, to select as far as possible the tunes to be sung at the public services of worship as well as the hymns and Psalms and that the organist be notified of the action."
 

An effort was made in 1884 to persuade the choir to sit up front, but evidently, they did not wish to do so, and continued to sing from the back balcony.
 

A Young People’s Society of Christian Endeavor was organized in 1893, and the next year a Junior Christian Endeavor Society was also begun. By 1905 they were supporting one of the church orphans in the Talladega Home (now the Presbyterian Home for Children). The names for these groups has changed several times, having been "Youth Fellowship," "Senior High Fellowship" and now the "Presbyterian Youth Connection."
 

The church has hosted the General Assembly of the former Presbyterian Church in the United States (the Southern church) three times - in 1869, only a few years after the organization of the southern branch, 1904, and 1969.
 

Eighteen ministers have served the church:
The Rev. John B. Warren
The Rev. Murdock Murphy
The Rev. James R. Johnston, 1830-34
The Rev. William T. Hamilton, 1834-54
The Rev. Henry Mandeville, 1855-58
The Rev. John Lord, 1858-59
Dr. James Ralston Burgett, 1860-1900
Dr. A. F. Carr, 1901-13
Dr. Henry Wade Dubose, 1914-19
Dr. William Taliaferro Thompson, 1919-20 (Moderator of the General Assembly, 1956)
Dr. Dunbar H. Ogden, 1920-30
Dr. Warner H. Dubose, 1931-41
Dr. Ansley C. Moore, 1942-47
Dr. John Chester Frist, 1947-59
Dr. Massey Mott Heltzel, 1960-73
Dr. Joe Bryan Donaho, 1974-88
Dr. James Lewis Johnson, 1989-92
Dr. Sidney Franklin Batts, 1995-2001
 

Dr. Burgett was the first minister married in the church. He and his wife, married in 1860, occupied the manse longer than any other family - forty years. (The second and only other such wedding where the minister himself was married in this church was that of Dr. Henry Wade Dubose and Miss Marie Webb on April 14, 1915.) Several of Dr. Burgett’s descendants are members of the church today.
[i] The Dead of the Synod of Alabama, by Mr. Robert Nall.

[ii] Charter members were:

Lucy Holt, Elizabeth Holt, Mary Ann Holt, Sarah Pryor, Sarah Hogan, Lydia Rolston, Sophia Eliot, Mary King, Ann Hitchcock, Thomas Reed, Alanson Knapp, John E. Shepherd, William Fisk, Phoebe Vincent, Eliza Casey, Hannah Chamberlain, Lucy Waterman, Sarah Howse, Margaret Eliot, Janet Edwards, Miles Treat, and Catherine Van Rensellaer Schuyler Hale

Called to Serve